Sickening Stuff
Monday, November 20th, 2006The Carnival Liberty cruise ship is docked in Port Everglades, Florida, today, undergoing what the cruise line calls a thorough scrubbing after a stomach illness spread to nearly 700 passengers and crew members. According to the Sun-Sentinel newspaper in Florida, it could be one of the largest outbreaks in the history of the cruise ship industry.
My favorite spin from this past weekend’s coverage is from a woman named Christine Fischer, a cruise industry spokeswoman. She told the Sun-Sentinel’s reporter that while these kinds of outbreaks receive a lot of publicity, they really are far less common than they seem.
Of course! Why didn’t I realize it’s the media’s fault for making this outbreak seem so bad? After all, who else could be to blame for nearly 25 percent of the people onboard vomiting and suffering from diarrhea for days on end? Certainly not the industry that reports dozens of viral outbreaks onboard its ships every year to America’s national Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
And let’s be clear about exactly what an outbreak means to people onboard a cruise ship. “Our cabin steward was struck, and we didn’t have anybody to clean our cabin for five days,” a Colorado woman told the Sun-Sentinel. She added that she and her husband spent two days vomiting in that very same cabin.
That’s sickening stuff, but not as sickening as the industry spin that these kinds of outbreaks are minimal at best. Ms. Fischer, to support her argument, told the Sun-Sentinal that these kinds of cruise-ship outbreaks affect only about one in every 3,600 passengers. It’s as if she were making the case that diarrhea, nausea, vomiting and abdominal pain are just a natural possibility when you decide to vacation at sea.
Not so with yacht charter. By my own estimates there are around a quarter-million weeks of yacht charter vacations being booked around the world each year, which means somewhere in the neighborhood of 2 million guests. Even if there were to be a “yacht-wide” outbreak of a stomach illness, it would affect only the guests and crew onboard a single charter yacht, which by international law can usually carry 12 guests maximum. If you assume the yacht has 12 crew, too (and even that’s a stretch), then the largest number of people who could ever be affected by a “yacht-wide” outbreak of a stomach virus is 24. Compare that to 700 on the Carnival ship, and the odds in your favor during a yacht charter are staggering.
I’m sure cruise-ship lobbyists like Ms. Fischer wish they had yacht charter’s statistics on their disposal, because it’s much easier to defend a style of cruising vacation where you’re actually likely to stay healthy, where you’re not putting yourself onto a floating city full of germs, where if there is for some reason a problem, you won’t be left to vomit in your cabin for a few days without so much as a fresh towel while the ship continues on its way to keep the rest of the paying passengers happy.
Yet again, I am reminded about just how much better yacht charter vacations are than cruise ship trips. Sometimes, it’ s not even about the personalized service, the flexible itineraries, and the crowd-free coves. Sometimes, it’s just about the basics, like being able to stay healthy while you’re trying to relax at sea.










