Great Expectations
Thursday, September 20th, 2007I spent literally all day yesterday–from about 8 a.m. till well after 6 p.m.–listening to press conferences and testimony before Congress about the issue of crime onboard cruise ships.
What an Alice in Wonderland-style rabbit hole. The industry says everything’s fine, that there really aren’t very many crimes at all. The victims stand up and say the industry is covering up crimes left and right to keep the official crime statistics low. Some elected officials try to get serious answers from both parties. Other officials complain about the fact that hearings are being held regarding an industry that donates mightily to their campaign coffers.
The saga will continue, as the cruise industry has been required to report back to Congress within 90 days about progress it is making to correct glaring deficiencies in safety practices and procedures. And I think, based on yesterday’s hearing, that Congress is at least going to require a neutral third party, such as the U.S. Coast Guard, to begin making cruise ship crime statistics available to the public.
This last bit caught my attention because of the way the hearing’s chairman, a thoughtful Democrat from Maryland, tried to get the cruise industry to accept public disclosure of cruise ship crime statistics. “People are smart,” he told a panel of industry executives. Vacationers who get onboard cruise ships should understand that bad things might happen. These large ships are, after all, floating cities. Covering up the crimes only makes them seem worse in the public eye.
The thing that crossed my mind during this commentary is that it’s ridiculous for anyone to have to anticipate violent crime when planning a cruising vacation. Why in the world would you choose to cruise in an environment where crime is at all likely to occur, let alone be covered up to the point that congressional hearings are required?
I respectfully disagree with the hearing’s chairman on this point. I think people should have great expectations about their cruising vacations, not fears of rape and robbery.
Which is, of course, why I continue to champion the idea of private charter yacht vacations instead of cruise ship trips. It’s just plain commonsense that a ship full of 4,000 to 6,000 strangers is not nearly as safe a place as a yacht carrying just you, your family, and the yacht owner’s personal staff.
I look forward to continued public disclosure and increased awareness about just how dangerous cruise ships may in fact be. Every time another cruise ship crime victim comes forward, it’s another chance for me to tell you about why you should choose private yacht charter for your family’s next vacation instead.










